Sci-fi survival turned nature show that's as beautiful as it is bizarre
SPOILERS
When it came to the story, I sometimes found the environmental wackiness to be stretched a bit too far, even by alien world standards. This tested the plausibility of the wildlife and the characters' interactions with the situation. I also had issues with the believability of the characters' journey across the land, which featured rapid changes in the biome every handful of miles, which, alongside some narrative pacing issues, made it difficult to grasp a sense of distance, place, and time—elements that are essential when striving for tension and realism in a survival-focused story. The hardships were never felt, and the overall narrative occasionally felt dull, overly focused on showcasing exaggerated hazards rather than capturing the perseverance that an expedition of this nature would genuinely require.
The characters were, for the most part decent, and I particularly enjoyed Azi and Levi's journey, which featured the strongest themes, some nice dialog and the first bit of meaningful tension with the introduction of the pirate crew. Sam and Ursula were likable but a little plain and predictable, and Kamen’s intentionally unlikable nature did in moments feel a bit one-dimensional and not an arc I looked forward to. That said, his more brutal moments and spectacular final hallucinatory scene were cool additions.
Taking the time to develop individual backstories was a nice touch to help with memorability, and the charming, understated performances of all the voice actors were solid too. The actual writing did feel disjointed at times and was generally not very engaging. I never felt particularly excited about the story being told, nor did I experience a strong emotional response to the various relationships and dynamics among the characters and the challenges they faced. That said, bringing everyone together at the downed Demeter for the climax was done really well and finished the series in a satisfying conclusion that could stand alone or serve as part of a larger tale.
Will that tale continue? It certainly deserves to. HBO canceled any plans for season 2, but Netflix has since moved the show to its platform (available in the US and UK only). With an Emmy nomination for animation, it may have enough to see itself given the green-light, although no words as of October 2024, so I will keep my expectations measured.
VERDICT
Scavengers Reign is a one-of-a-kind visual feast for the eyes, with addicting animation, a well crafted soundtrack, and moments of off-world brilliance. While the story serves as a solid vehicle for the visionary natural world to flourish, it is not particularly gripping, lacking some needed grit and realism amongst the pastoral and surreal. It still had me eager for each new episode, with a foundation of decent characters and themes that do just about enough to sustain interest until the impressive climax lands. A sprinkling of world-building hinted at a larger narrative and universe beyond Vestor Minor, leaving much to be excited about if we do get a season 2, I just hope that next time it brings a bit a little more substance to the story, with a level of quality and craft to match its stunning visuals.
RATING BREAKDOWN
Story:
66
Directing:
72
Visuals:
93
Acting / Dialogue:
77
Music / Sound:
78
BONUS
Art direction
animation
FINAL
GIF LOADING
GIF LOADING